Grilled Potato Salad with Shallot Lemon Vinagrette

Potato salad without mayo? Oh yeah! Grilled potatoes are a classic side dish.
30 Min
5 Min.
Our grilled potato salad is a true feast of textures and tastes: crunchy and creamy at the same time, seasoned with a shallot-scallion-mustard vinaigrette and grilled lemons. The trick is to pre-cook the potatoes and give them the final crunch with the Otto Grill. By pre-cooking, the potatoes’ surface produces a film of starch which gets extra crispy when you broil the potatoes on the Otto Grill. Grilling the lemons gives them extra sweetness and flavor. The perfect grill side dish for your steak! And for all vegetarians out there: it's so good you can enjoy it as a main course!
Serves 4
    • Salt
    • 2 Tbsps fresh chopped oregano
    • 2 Tbsps chopped parsley
    • 4 Chopped cloves of garlic
    • Olive oil
    • Freshly ground black pepper
    • 4 Scallions thinly sliced
    • 2 Tbsps chopped shallots
    • 1 Tbsp whole grain mustard
    • 1 Lemon





    Potatoes are a classic, but dress ’em up nice and crispy-like with a fresh vinagrette and you’ve got the fanciest most snackable treat straight from the Otto Grill! It’s everyone’s favorite from vegan to carnivore – so serve ’em up hot!

    Step 1

    Precook potatoes

    Boil potatoes in a big pot with salted water. When cooked, drain potatoes and let the excess moisture evaporate.

    Step 2

    Prepare potatoes for grill

    Let the potatoes cool down a bit so that you can handle them comfortably. Cut them in half lengthwise and put them in a big bowl. Add half of the chopped oregano, half of the parsley, half of the garlic and a bit of olive oil. Save the rest of the herbs for the vinagrette. Mix everything together. Season to taste with salt and pepper and toss until the potatoes‘ surfaces are a little roughed up or “rustic.”

    Tip: You can also put the potatoes on a hard surface and smash them a tiny bit – take care not to smash the whole thing (but if you do, they become extra crispy potato snacks!)

    Step 3

    Prep the vinaigrette

    For the vinaigrette, mix the remaining oregano, parsley, garlic, scallions, shallots and mustard in a bowl and toss. Add olive oil.

    Step 4

    Prepare to grill potatoes

    Preheat the Otto Grill. Put the potato halves into an oven-safe deep dish and place it on the grill grate. Adjust the height of the grate to Meat-O-Meter Level 3-4 and grill the potatoes at low heat until they become golden (5 mins). Turn occasionally so that the potatoes are grilled from all sides. As soon as the potatoes are crispy and golden brown, remove dish from the grill. Put the potatoes into a big bowl and mix with the shallot lemon vinaigrette.

    Step 5

    Serve crispy grilled potato salad

    Cut the lemon in halves. Place cut-side-up directly under the heat and broil until they are slightly brown. Squeeze grilled lemons on top of potatoes. Add vinaigrette and toss well so that the potatoes are evenly covered with herbs, lemon and olive oil. Season to taste with salt and pepper and serve warm.

    Did you make this? Tell us how you went!